The story
Devon sells graded trading cards. His inventory is thousands of items and every single one is quantity one, so the defining fact of his store is that his best-ranking pages are the ones that already sold.
His titles are the shorthand he uses at the shop: set abbreviation, card number, grader, grade. Collectors search the same things spelled out in full, plus the year and the condition, and none of that vocabulary was in his listings.
Writing set, year, grade and condition into every listing, and redirecting sold items to the set page instead of a 404, turned a catalog that quietly destroyed its own SEO every week into one that compounds.